IW Kaiyun logo IW KaiyunFootball tactics, culture, and player development
Fan Culture

How Fanzines Survived the Internet and Still Matter

There is a man who sells a fanzine outside the away turnstiles at a ground I visit twice a season. Two pounds, cash, A5, stapled slightly off centre.

A stapled A5 football fanzine held open on a stadium concourse with supporters walking past

There is a man who sells a fanzine outside the away turnstiles at a ground I visit twice a season. Two pounds, cash, A5, stapled slightly off centre. Last February I bought one while three people next to me were reading the club's own app, which had just pushed a notification telling us the team news we could see on the big screen anyway. The fanzine had a 900 word piece arguing that the manager's double pivot was wasting the only left footed passer in the squad. It was better than anything I read about that match afterwards, and the writer had no byline photo and no follower count.

That gap is the reason this piece exists. Fan media got louder over the last fifteen years and lost almost all of its accountability on the way. A fanzine has a print run, a seller who stands in front of you next week, and about 40 pages to fill with something a reader will not get from the official channel. Those three constraints do more for quality than any amount of engagement.

What a fanzine was, and what took its place

The format arrived properly in the mid 1980s. When Saturday Comes started in 1986 and is still published monthly, which makes it older than most of the supporters it writes for. Single club titles followed in waves, with United We Stand appearing in 1989 and dozens of others living and dying within a season or two. The economics were simple: photocopying, a staple gun, and a friend willing to stand in the cold.

What replaced them was not one thing. Match reaction went to video, rumour went to aggregator accounts, and tactical writing went to blogs and then to subscription newsletters. Each of those does one slice of the job well. None of them does what a single issue did, which was to put a match report, a financial grumble, a letters page, and a joke about a rival's new kit in the same reader's hands on the same afternoon. Breadth was the product, and breadth is exactly what an algorithm removes.

The letters page is the part I miss most as a coach. People wrote in to disagree, their disagreement got printed next to the piece it attacked, and the editor had to live with both. Replies now sit in a thread that the original writer can mute.

The internet did not kill the fanzine

This is the line everyone repeats, and I think it is wrong in a way that matters if you want to start one. Titles did not fold because readers left for free writing online. They folded because distribution collapsed.

Three things happened at roughly the same time at most grounds. Stewarding tightened and sellers were pushed off the forecourt onto the pavement, sometimes 200 metres from the turnstile. Clubs redeveloped their approaches into controlled fan zones with commercial agreements, and an independent seller does not fit a commercial agreement. Cash stopped being something people carried. I watched a seller lose maybe half his trade in two seasons without a single reader deciding he was worse than a podcast.

The titles that survived solved distribution rather than content. They went to monthly print with postal subscriptions, sold through a handful of independent shops, and treated the matchday sale as a bonus. When Saturday Comes has done this for decades. The lesson is unglamorous: if you want to publish, work out how the thing reaches a hand before you write a word of it. Fan organisations that already have a mailing list have a head start, which is one of several reasons a supporters trust is worth joining even if you never intend to vote on anything.

What print still does better than a thread

Four things, and only four. I would not claim more than that.

It is finished. An issue goes to the printer and stops changing, so the writer has to be right on the day rather than correcting in replies. It is finite, so a 2,500 word argument has to earn its space against the fixture list and the letters. It is slow, which filters out the reaction pieces that exist only because something happened in the last hour. And it is physical, which means it gets passed along, read on a train, and kept in a box in a loft for twenty years. I still have about 30 issues from my playing days, and the tactical pieces have aged far better than the transfer gossip.

What it does worse is obvious. No corrections, no links, no pictures worth looking at unless somebody pays for decent paper, and a six week lag between writing and reading. Anyone starting a title should accept those as the cost of the first four.

The realistic numbers for starting one

I have helped two people cost this out, and both were surprised in the same direction. Print is cheaper than they feared and the rest is harder.

  1. Decide the run before the content. Below about 200 copies, a digital print shop charges you per page and the unit cost stays near a pound for a 36 page A5 booklet. Past 500 copies, litho printing drops that sharply. Pick the band you can genuinely sell and design to it.
  2. Find your pitch, literally. Walk the approach to the ground on a matchday and identify the spot where people slow down and still have 10 minutes to spare. Ask the stewarding supervisor rather than the club's media office, because the supervisor is the person who will move you on.
  3. Sort payment before issue one. A card reader costs about 30 pounds and will carry over half your sales. A printed account name on the cover for bank transfers picks up more than you expect from people who read it later.
  4. Commit to four issues, not one. A single issue is a stunt. Readers judge whether to care at issue three, and writers only start sending you unsolicited pieces once they believe the thing will exist in two months.
  5. Keep one page for the argument you will lose. Print the letter that says you were wrong about the defensive midfielder. That page is why people trust the other 35.

Budget roughly 250 pounds and six weekends for a first issue of 300 copies, assuming nobody gets paid. Both of the people I helped came out slightly under that, and both spent more time on distribution than on editing.

Where to find them now

Outside grounds, still, at maybe a third of clubs in the English pyramid, and more in Germany and Italy. Independent bookshops near a ground often take a few copies. Groundhoppers trade them, which is a good reason to ask in the away end rather than online. If you are travelling somewhere new and want the honest version of a club's current mood, spend two pounds at the gate before you spend anything in the club shop. The same instinct that goes into planning a tifo display tends to go into the local title, and both tell you who is actually organised in those stands.

One concrete step for this week, if any of this appealed. Pick your next away fixture, search the club's name with the word fanzine, and buy whatever comes up. If nothing comes up and your own club has no title either, you have found the gap. More writing about football exists in our fan culture section, but none of it will be about your left back.

FAQ

Do clubs try to shut fanzines down?

Rarely now, and almost never over content. The friction is commercial and spatial: who is allowed to sell what on club land. Most press offices are indifferent, and a few quietly supply quotes. The exception is a title that names individual staff in disputes, which is where a club's lawyers get involved.

Can a fanzine be digital and still count?

It can, and several are. What usually disappears is the editing discipline, because a file with no printing deadline keeps growing. The versions that work set a fixed release day and a page limit anyway, which is an odd thing to do to a PDF but it keeps the thing readable.

How much writing does one issue need?

Between 8,000 and 12,000 words for a 36 page booklet once you allow for images and a cover. That sounds enormous until you count a match report, two opinion pieces, a letters page, and an interview with somebody who works at the ground. Three regular contributors can hold that pace.

Is there any money in it?

Not really. At 300 copies and two pounds a copy you cover print and little else. The titles that pay anybody do it through subscriptions and a small amount of advertising from local businesses, and they took years to get there.

CA
Callum Ashworth

Callum spent years coaching at semi-professional level before moving to writing full time. He watches matches back at half speed more often than he would like to admit, and writes about tactics the way he used to explain them to his own squad.

More posts by Callum

More in Fan Culture

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto